Author Archives: S.C. Karakaltsas

Unknown's avatar

About S.C. Karakaltsas

I am a published author of historical fiction and short stories.

Book Review: John of John by Douglas Stuart

Down and out with little prospects, John-Callum McLeod, Cal for short, heads home from art school to help look after his grandmother who lives with his father, John on a small island off the coast of Scotland.

At the outset the writing is exquisite and the reader is immediately immersed into the isolation, desolation and poverty of this tiny god-fearing community.

Cal is a gay man which he hides from his family and slides right back into his home never fully meeting his father’s expectations. Cal’s mother lives further away and what he doesn’t know is the reason his parents split up is because his father is also gay. John lives a tormented and secret life within walking distance from his long-time love.  The secrets of this island have a way of pulling the reader in.

The harshness and isolation is everywhere and the community is stuck in old traditions and fake piousness which settles uncomfortably in a modern world. You could be forgiven for thinking the book is set a hundred years ago but it’s quite current whereas the thinking is not.

Cal’s journey and that of his father unfolds allowing the reader to relate to their everyday life, it’s ups and downs wondering if anything will ever change. Fortunately, it eventually does.  

This is shortlisted for the Booker Prize for 2026 and I’m not surprised. Check this one out.

Book Review: The Dig Tree: The Story of Bravery, Insanity, and the Race to Discover Australia’s Wild Frontier by Sarah Murgatroyd

The title for this book nails it.

This is the story of the doomed exploration by Burke and Wills across the Australian continent. I had to reach back through my memory to my childhood to recollect a perception that the trek was tragic but that Burke and Wills were heroes. This book reveals what a debacle the whole thing was and I certainly questioned their hero status. But in a new colony in 1860, the colonial rule, class system and pure ignorance of the landscape and seasons were against these men from the outset.

Murgatroyd does a brilliant job retracing their footsteps in minute detail laying out the very personalities of Burke the trek leader and Wills the only surveyor who had enough knowledge to navigate the country. Indeed, what we learn about Burke is truly eye-opening. The culpability of the people in The Royal Society who put the expedition together reflected the thinking around class and privilege and not experience, for Burke was a policeman not an explorer.

The true tragedy of this book is that the author did not live long enough to enjoy the accolades about her book as she succumbed to breast cancer soon after it was published more than twenty years ago.

It’s a well written and wonderfully paced book which enlightens us about the era, the people, and the politics of this ill-fated journey. It’s fast paced and a page-turner and I loved it.

Check this one out.

Book Review: The Names by Florence Knapp

This one is a powerhouse of a novel.

Cora sets off with her nine-year-old daughter to register the name of her newborn son. Her GP husband Gordon has given her explicit instructions that his son is to be named after him as per his family tradition. But when the time comes to fill out the paperwork, Cora has doubts.

Spanning the next thirty-five years, Knapp plots a course for the three names Cora may have chosen for her son and the consequences upon not just his life but hers as well.

The three versions of the boy’s life as Gordon, Julian and Bear are gripping, harrowing and completely imaginative. The version of Gordon is the most difficult and given the themes of domestic violence can be very challenging to read. Fortunately, the chapters are short to allow the reader to draw breath and relief. But the switch into the new name and timeline means extra focus to remember each boy’s life version. Reading this one in long blocks would help which isn’t too hard since it’s a page turner. The themes of domestic violence, coercive control crossing all sections of the community was enlightening as it was sobering.

I can see why this one has made such an impact in the book world. Check this one out.

Book Review: In a Common Hour by Sita Walker

Set in a State High school in QLD is teacher Paul Bush and his students who are in their last year. A disgruntled student does something devastating during a one-hour lunchtime which has devastating consequences changing Paul Bush’s life and impacting the students around him.

If you’re not a teacher, you will appreciate how difficult this profession is and if you are then a lot of this will hit home. Walker delivers believable characters in a genuine setting of a busy high school. It’s a compelling read and the writing captures the atmosphere brilliantly.

Each chapter represents a brief time block in the hour and at times it’s hard to believe so much happens within that time. Yet it seems to work considering it’s a fairly short novel.

The only down side is the number of characters and because I read this over a couple of days,  I was able to keep up and remember them all—just.

It’s a brave world out there in schools and I take my hat off to all the wonderful teachers who try to do the best they can.

Check this one out.

Book Review: Whistler by Ann Patchett

An intriguing story about Daphne who unexpectantly runs into her mother’s second husband, Eddie at a museum. He had only been married a year but had left a lasting impact on nine-year-old Daphne who believed the break up was her fault. The last time she’d seen him was when they were in a car accident and she had  trudged through snow to save him.

This is a beautifully told story about love and loss and how two people can have a profound impact on each other. Both Daphne and Eddie are propelled back to their once loving relationship almost immediately their bond barely broken

Daphne relays the story of the accident to her sister in snippets. Yet her sister being younger, didn’t have quite the same relationship and at times disappears in the story while Daphne and Eddie reignite their love for one another.

The characters are endearing and thoughtful even Jonathan, Daphne’s husband. Daphne herself is complicated as she is likeable. The story told through her eyes, reveals her pain and loss as well as her heartfelt relationships.

This is a lovely gentle story. Check it out.

Book Review: Strangers by Belle Burden

You would think the story line of a wife who comes home and finds her husband has been unfaithful to be of little interest to anyone.

Except this memoir is a highly compelling and voyeuristic look inside a world of privilege and the disintegration of a relationship.

I was captured hook, line, sinker with this one. The writing is truly beautiful and the author engages the reader about her life, the tragedy, and the fallout affecting her friends, family and neighbours. It shines a light on the societal norms of the nuclear family and the class structure she experiences in her Martha Vineyard home all while with Covid lurks in the sidelines.

The author is no celebrity but she does have wealth which was taken advantage of by her philandering husband who kept his obscene hedge fund salary a secret. To be fair, she admitted she had no interest in their finances trusting him completely. And many relationships do that and it’s all fine until it isn’t. Every person should understand their financial situation and it’s got nothing to do with trust. If he’d died suddenly, she would have had to face it anyway—lesson learned.

I was captivated with this story, how the husband managed a double life and it played on my mind as to how these men actually think. We get no more of an explanation of this betrayal than Burden did. But the signs were there. He leaves the parenting to her, wants the prenup changed, convinces her that his long hours at work is for the family, agrees that her trust fund should be used to buy property in joint names without contribution from him. Is it hindsight or her ignorance about what their relationship truly looked like?

The disintegration of one woman’s life and how she picked up the pieces was engaging enough. Check this one out.

Book Review: Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke

Whoa this book has really done my head in and I’ve needed time to digest and process what just happened.

Natalie is an influencer raising her large family on a farm and posting about her daily life with her handsome cowboy husband and her perfectly styled kitchen and well-behaved children. It seems she has it all and her followers lap it up despite the fact Natalie has lots of paid help.

However, she wakes one morning cast back into the 1800’s with her same family, same farm house and same husband. But something isn’t quite right.

The story is told in two timelines: her life in the present as a traditional wife and her backstory. The other tells how she navigates her life back in history. From the first page I was hooked because all I wanted to know was how she had time travelled back to the 1800’s.

I loved the two-time line structure and her backstory. The writing was very good too. However, her life in the 1800’s was quite brutal and confronting. Was she held a prisoner, had she time travelled or was she merely suffering some sort of nightmare dream? I won’t put any spoilers in here but there were quite a few holes when I looked back on that second timeline e.g she suffers an injury but no help is called. I couldn’t buy into the callousness of that.

Nevertheless, it’s a wild ride and I can see why it’s captured many readers. I did come away feeling very little for Natalie’s character. Her husband even more so. She really was the angry woman and the question is why she put up with it all for so long. I did wonder though if she was an unreliable narrator and when you consider that, the whole thing is barely believable. If anything it’s quite a sad story.

This would be a great book club pick because it would no doubt ignite a lot of debate. Check it out if you haven’t already.