Tag Archives: Book reviews

Book Review: The Marriage Portrait by Maggie O’Farrell

2 Replies

My first encounter with this author was reading her novel, Hamnet. In my opinion, The Marriage Portrait is even better.

O’Farrell was inspired by the real life story of fifteen-year-old Lucrezia di Cosimo de’Medici who, in 1560 married the Duke of Ferrara, Alfonso II d’Este. A year later Lucrezia died officially from a ‘putrid fever’. However, rumours circulated that she was indeed murdered by her husband.

And so O’Farrell begins her story on the day when Lucrezia’s realizes she is in danger. O’Farrell then weaves the story back and forth between that day and through Lucrezia’s life. We learn about her childhood as the middle child of a large and powerful noble family, her betrothal and eventual marriage.

We are immediately transported into Lucrezia’s life, inhabiting her thoughts, observations, and intelligence. She has great talents and had she been a male would likely have made a great ruler. But alas, the bindings of being a woman mean that she is cast into a role she does not want, that of a wife and breeder of children. And that of course is in keeping with the time and for years since. In our present day it nevertheless is galling as we cheer on her struggles for recognition and rights.

The structure of the story is clever as the two timelines converge towards a tense crescendo so much so that you cannot put it down.

There is a lot of description and sometimes I find in some stories that it can serve to slow the story down. Not the case for The Marriage Portrait as each detail puts us in Lucrezia’s point of view understanding her surroundings and her acute observations of people which serves to paint a complete picture of her world.

It is a masterpiece of writing, the characters so detailed that we know and fear for them.

This is definitely one to read. Don’t miss out.

Book Review: Mayflies by Andrew O’Hagan

2 Replies

This is a tender yet heart-breaking story about love and friendship and how far you would go for your friends.

This is Jimmy’s story about his friendship with Tully who took him into his family after his parents abandoned him. The first half of the novel is about the growth and depth of their relationship at a pivotal point when they travel with a group of friends from Glasgow to Manchester for a weekend of music, drugs, drinking and everything else in between. The second half fast forwards thirty years ahead when Tully rings Jimmy and breaks devastating news and asks for help.

The novel is filled with humour even in the darkest of moments. It is also a telling portrayal of life during the Thatcher years where each boy’s political views are shaped by the economic woes forced on them and their families by the collapse of the coal mines. Music is their escape and for one weekend they lose themselves in youthful exuberance.

Even though I read the novel, I could hear the Scottish lilt in the dialogue. The writing is beautiful and particularly evocative of the era of 1986. Yet the author also captured the same boys as men and where they’d landed. Jimmy and Tully chose the path they wanted on that weekend seeking a better life and for the most part achieved that. Foremost, their relationship never weakened by the years and only grew stronger.

Revealing the request Tully makes would be a spoiler but let’s just say the mood changes markedly dealing with a distressing yet important topic. The reader is faced with contemplating the uncomfortable dilemma Jimmy is put into and wondering how they would respond.

Give this one a go but be warned it’s a heavy topic.

Book Review: Naked Ambition by Robert Gott

Leave a reply

This is a light-hearted, humorous look at family relationships and the world of politics.

Young MP Gregory Buchanan has been elevated to the Minister for Education and is facing an election when he shows his wife a painting he recently commissioned of himself. His excitement is soon overshadowed by his wife’s disapproval and dismay. She is in PR and realizes that the portrait of him fully nude will do him no favours. His mother-in-law, a Christian zealot is horrified and his mother is not keen. Throw in the female premier’s disapproval and you have quite a situation particularly after the painting is stolen.

I enjoyed the characters particularly the gin and tonic toting mother and the Christian die hard mother-in-law. The dynamics between these two made for some laugh out loud moments. In fact, I imagined this book as a play with sharp-witted repartee between the main players being the hapless Gregory, his wife and the two mothers together with his sister and the premier. Being the only male character, Gregory is constantly on the back foot and when the artist who is also female threatens him, we have an interesting twist.

I found some of the dialogue repartee, a little laboured and repetitive at times as the two major scenes were in the Buchanan’s house with the same characters. Apart from this it is a short read with enjoyable twists which likened it a little to an episode of Yes Minister. A fun read which many will enjoy.

Book Review: A Disappearance in Fiji by Nilima Rao

Leave a reply

A novel set in Fiji in 1914 about a missing indentured Indian woman was bound to be intriguing. This debut historical fiction by Australian author Nilima Rao was a page-turner, enlightening the reader about the conditions of Indian Indentured workers early last century.

A young Sikh policeman, Akal Singh is posted from Hong Kong to Fiji in disgrace.  He is sent to a distant cane plantation to find a missing indentured Indian woman. The plantation owner declares she has run off with the overseer with whom she has been having an affair. A parish priest challenges that by saying she’s been kidnapped.  When Singh arrives at the plantation, he finds that not all is what it seems and he is shocked by the work conditions of his fellow countrymen.

There are several themes in this book, the colonial system, racism as well as the class divide not just between the races but even within the Indian community. Of course, sexism is explored and the way women are treated, where questions of justice and morals contradict the system of exploitation by the colonial system. The brutality and squalor of the indentured system was well portrayed.

 I liked the comradery between Akal and the white doctor who is pleasingly on the side of justice. There are times where I yearned for Akal to look a little wider, his investigation slow at first but becomes more energetic as his confidence grows.

 It makes for a very compelling story with a nice twist at the end. Yet it still lends itself to a sequel. I’ll look out for that one.

Book Review: Bruny by Heather Rose

Leave a reply

Books about Tasmania by Tasmanians rarely seem to put a foot wrong for me lately and Bruny is no exception.

It is a fantastical story of a time in the future when a bridge costing two billion dollars is constructed to Bruny Island a short distance from Hobart. For those who know Tasmania and in particular, Bruny Island, the place is not highly populated nor would it warrant a six-lane bridge. Understandably an explosion which collapses part of the bridge brings Astrid Coleman, a UN negotiator home from the USA to help her brother, the premier get the bridge repaired before the next election.

While central to the book is the bridge, there are many other issues the author freely explores. One is the destruction of the environment, both sea and land. It is well known that the waters around this particular area have been polluted by fish farming and this is spelled out again with the advent of a bridge and tourists. The author doesn’t hold back on the political aspects and I enjoyed this immensely as she foresees into the future pinpointing Chinese influence and economic colonialization. She also throws a jab at the AFL and considering that Tasmania has just been allocated a team in the recent month she was remarkably accurate in her forecast back when she wrote this prior to 2019.

The author is passionate about what Tasmania has and what is stands to lose, forecasting the consequences of the climate crisis. The future may not be that unrealistic.

There is also a love story and one of family together with loyalty and the challenge of allegiance. But more importantly, it is a story of being home and finding the joy of the land we’ve grown up on and where we really belong.

There are many issues in this book which will have you nodding your head in agreement as you turn the page not wanting to put this down.

It’s well written, easy to read and highly topical. It makes me want to head back to Bruny Island again to see it while it still is pristine.

Put this one on your list.

The Fortune Men by Nadifa Mohamed

Leave a reply

This book was shortlisted for the Booker Prize in 2021 and was a book club pick for May.

It’s 1952. Mahmood Mattan lives in Cardiff and is a petty criminal walking the streets for opportunity. He’s cheeky, a pick-pocket, gambler and a proud Somalian. He is also deeply in love with his three young boys and his estranged wife. When he is accused of murdering a white Jewish woman, he believes in the English legal system and his innocence. His belief slowly crumbles amidst lies, mistaken identity and a system where privilege is not within his reach.

It’s a heart-breaking story and there is no happy ending. If anything, the carriage of injustice makes you angry and depressed. Mahmood is certainly a scallywag which he acknowledges but he admits he’s not a murderer. His blind faith in the legal system reveals the incompetence of all involved and all he has is the undying love of his wife and boys which of course only serves to make it all the more sad.

It is inspired by a true story as revealed at the end where justice was continually sought for years after. But what the author does is humanise the very details, putting us in Mahmood’s shoes, feeling all that he does. And it’s uncomfortable as we experience his fading hope.

It’s a descriptive book, probably a little too much for me as it slowed the story down. Yet the writing is beautiful so I can understand the shortlisting elevation.

It’s not a happy read but it is one about injustice, racial divides, and privilege. And that makes it an important one to read.

Book Review: The Christie Affair by Nina de Gramont

Leave a reply

I picked up this novel because I’d seen a documentary about Agatha Christie’s life and was particularly intrigued about the eleven days in 1926 when Agatha disappeared. Her explanation at the time was that she had no memory of what happened.

Agatha was known for her detective novels but her fame was minor until her disappearance, when her car was found abandoned, her fur coat and case still in it. Where did she go? What happened?  De Gramont reimagines the events of those eleven days which makes for a very compelling and twisted tale.

For a start the story is from the point of view of Nan O’Dea who is the lover of Agatha’s husband. Her story, tragic and traumatic made for some very difficult reading yet it was so compelling. I enjoyed the way Nan and Agatha’s story intersected and when Nan’s motivation is finally revealed our sympathy for her certainly escalates.

De Gramont highlights the class divide beautifully and the plight of single pregnant women, the Catholic church, abuse and the role of women in their ‘proper’ place as wives to look after their husbands.

We are given various points of view, though mainly it is told by Nan. At times, it almost seemed a little far-fetched as a double murder occurs reminiscent of one of Agatha’s own stories, until the twist towards the end reveals a plausible  connection to her.

This one was definitely a page-turner and quite well-written. How close it is to any semblance of truth? We will never know.